Pakistan's Urbanization and Agricultural Development

Since Pakistan's independence in 1947, the country has experienced significant transformations, particularly in urbanization and agricultural development. These changes have profoundly influenced Pakistan's economy, environment, and social fabric. Urbanization, which refers to the increasing concentration of populations in urban areas, has played a critical role in shaping the nation's ecological processes and development patterns. However, this rapid urbanization, coupled with population growth, has raised concerns about the sustainability of these changes, particularly regarding the conversion of agricultural land into residential areas.

The Evolution of Urbanization in Pakistan

In the early years following independence, Pakistan was primarily an agrarian society. The majority of the population lived in rural areas, and agriculture was the backbone of the economy. The partition of British India in 1947 led to a massive migration of people across the newly drawn borders, which significantly impacted the demographic landscape of the country. Cities like Karachi, Lahore, and Rawalpindi saw a rapid influx of refugees, which marked the beginning of accelerated urbanization.

As Pakistan embarked on its journey of nation-building, the focus was initially on developing infrastructure, industries, and services in urban centers. This urban-centric development strategy was aimed at modernizing the country and fostering economic growth. However, this approach also led to the neglect of rural areas and the agricultural sector. Over time, the disparity between urban and rural areas grew, prompting a migration of people from villages to cities in search of better opportunities.

The Shift in Land Use and Its Implications

The expansion of urban areas has come at a significant cost to agricultural land. The transformation of fertile farmland into residential and commercial areas has been a pressing issue, especially in the last few decades. According to Bhutto and Bazmi (2017), there has been a staggering 169.51% decrease in agricultural land over the past 20 years. This alarming trend highlights the unplanned and haphazard development of infrastructure and the uncontrolled expansion of cities.

The population of Pakistan's urban centers has nearly doubled in the last two decades, leading to a host of challenges. Cities like Karachi, Lahore, and Islamabad have witnessed explosive growth, resulting in severe problems such as water scarcity, traffic congestion, deforestation, housing shortages, rising crime rates, and numerous healthcare issues (Mohsin & Anwar et al., 2019). These challenges are a direct consequence of unplanned urbanization, which has strained the existing infrastructure and resources.

The Economic Significance of Agriculture

Despite the rapid urbanization, agriculture remains a cornerstone of Pakistan's economy. The sector contributes 24% to the country's GDP and provides employment to 37.4% of the workforce (Economic Survey of Pakistan, 2024). Additionally, agriculture is vital for food security and the supply of raw materials to various industries. More than 65% of Pakistan's population is directly or indirectly dependent on agriculture for their livelihood.

The loss of agricultural land to urban development poses a significant threat to the country's food security and economic stability. The conversion of fertile land into housing societies has led to a reduction in crop production, exacerbating food shortages and increasing reliance on imports. This trend is particularly concerning in Punjab, the most fertile region of Pakistan, where 20% to 30% of the land has been consumed by housing schemes (Zahoor & Awan, 2023).

Historical Context: Urbanization Post-Independence

The historical trajectory of urbanization in Pakistan can be traced back to the early years of independence when the government prioritized industrialization and urban development. The 1950s and 1960s saw the establishment of major industries and infrastructure projects in urban areas, which attracted a large rural workforce to cities. This period also witnessed the Green Revolution, which brought about significant changes in agricultural practices, leading to increased productivity. However, the benefits of the Green Revolution were largely confined to specific regions and did not address the growing urban-rural divide.

During the 1970s and 1980s, urbanization continued to accelerate, driven by population growth and rural-urban migration. The government launched various housing schemes and development projects to accommodate the rising urban population. However, these initiatives often lacked proper planning and regulation, leading to the unchecked expansion of cities into surrounding agricultural lands.

The 1990s and early 2000s marked a period of rapid urbanization, driven by economic liberalization and globalization. The construction of private housing societies became a lucrative business, with developers acquiring large tracts of agricultural land on the outskirts of cities. The lack of comprehensive land-use policies and weak enforcement mechanisms allowed this trend to continue unabated, resulting in the large-scale conversion of farmland into residential areas.

The Challenges of Rapid Urbanization

The rapid urbanization of Pakistan has brought about numerous challenges that require urgent attention from policymakers. One of the most pressing issues is the shortage of housing. The country's urban population growth rate stands at 3%, making Pakistan the seventh most populous country in the world. There is an estimated shortage of 10 million housing units, which is expected to grow to 13% by the end of 2025 (Zameen.com). This housing deficit has driven up property prices, making homeownership increasingly unaffordable for many citizens.

The demand for urban housing is increasing by approximately 350,000 units annually, yet the supply remains insufficient (State Bank of Pakistan). The gap between demand and supply has led to the proliferation of informal settlements and slums, further exacerbating the challenges of urbanization. These informal settlements often lack basic amenities such as clean water, sanitation, and healthcare, contributing to poor living conditions and public health issues.

The expansion of housing societies has also had a detrimental impact on the environment. The conversion of agricultural land into residential areas has led to deforestation, loss of biodiversity, and a decrease in clean water supply. The construction of new roads, buildings, and infrastructure has increased the demand for natural resources, leading to over-exploitation and environmental degradation.

The Agriculture-Urbanization Nexus

The relationship between urbanization and agriculture is complex and multifaceted. While urbanization is often seen as a driver of economic growth and modernization, it can also undermine the agricultural sector if not managed properly. The loss of agricultural land to urban development reduces the availability of arable land for farming, which in turn affects food production and food security.

In Pakistan, the agricultural sector is already facing numerous challenges, including water scarcity, outdated farming techniques, and lack of investment in research and development. The additional pressure of losing fertile land to urbanization further weakens the sector's ability to contribute to the economy and provide for the population. The decline in agricultural productivity can lead to increased food prices, inflation, and greater dependency on food imports, which can strain the country's foreign exchange reserves.

The urbanization-agriculture nexus also has social implications. As rural populations migrate to urban areas in search of better opportunities, the rural economy suffers from a loss of labor and human capital. This migration can lead to the depopulation of rural areas, weakening the social fabric and disrupting traditional farming practices. The displaced rural population often faces challenges in adapting to urban life, leading to issues such as unemployment, poverty, and social marginalization.

Policy Recommendations for Sustainable Urbanization

Given the challenges posed by rapid urbanization and declining agricultural land, it is imperative for Pakistan to adopt policies that promote sustainable development. The following policy recommendations can help manage urbanization trends and protect agricultural land:

Comprehensive Legislation on Land Use

The government must implement strict zoning laws that designate specific areas for residential, commercial, industrial, and agricultural purposes. This legislation should include clear guidelines for the use of agricultural land for non-agricultural activities, with mandatory assessments of the economic and environmental impacts before approval.

Countries like the Netherlands have implemented strict land-use planning policies that protect agricultural land while allowing for sustainable urban growth. These policies can serve as a model for Pakistan.

Strengthening Enforcement Mechanisms

Local governments should be empowered with the resources and authority to enforce land-use regulations effectively. This includes establishing robust monitoring systems to track land-use changes and holding violators accountable through penalties or land reclamation.

Singapore's Urban Redevelopment Authority (URA) has a strong enforcement mechanism that ensures compliance with land-use regulations, helping to balance urban development with environmental conservation.

Promotion of Sustainable Urban Planning

Smart growth strategies should be adopted to manage urban expansion. This includes promoting vertical expansion (high-rise buildings) over horizontal expansion, preserving greenbelts and agricultural zones around cities, and encouraging the development of compact, walkable communities.

In Germany, cities like Freiburg have implemented sustainable urban planning practices that promote density, reduce urban sprawl, and preserve surrounding agricultural land.

Support for Agricultural Innovation

Investment in research and development is essential to enhance agricultural productivity using existing farmland. Modern farming techniques, such as precision agriculture and sustainable irrigation, should be promoted to increase yields and reduce the environmental impact of farming.

Israel has made significant advancements in agricultural technology, such as drip irrigation and hydroponics, which have enabled the country to increase agricultural productivity despite limited land and water resources.

Stakeholder Engagement and Public Awareness

Public awareness campaigns are crucial for educating citizens about the importance of preserving agricultural land and the consequences of unplanned urbanization. Additionally, involving stakeholders such as urban planners, farmers, civil society, and policymakers in the legislative process can lead to more balanced and effective policies.

In the United States, community-based organizations often play a key role in advocating for sustainable land-use practices and engaging the public in urban planning processes.

Strategic Implementation and Monitoring

To ensure the successful implementation of these policies, a strategic approach is necessary. This includes:

1. Existing land-use laws should be reviewed and updated to reflect current challenges and opportunities. New legislation and amendments should be proposed to strengthen the legal framework for sustainable urbanization.

2. Government planners and officials should receive training in sustainable land-use practices and the enforcement of regulations. This will enhance their ability to implement policies effectively.

3. Pilot programs in high-risk areas can be launched to test the effectiveness of new policies. These programs should be monitored closely, and lessons learned should be used to refine and improve the policies.

4. A permanent monitoring and evaluation system should be established to assess the impact of legislation and make continuous adjustments as needed. This system should involve regular data collection, analysis, and reporting to ensure transparency and accountability.

Conclusion

The future of Pakistan's agricultural sector and urban development is at a critical juncture. The rapid urbanization and decline in agricultural land present significant challenges that require immediate and comprehensive action. By implementing effective policies and strategies, Pakistan can achieve a balance between urban expansion and the preservation of agricultural land, ensuring food security, supporting rural livelihoods, and promoting sustainable development. The lessons learned from other countries' experiences can guide Pakistan in crafting a path that fosters economic growth while protecting the environment and the well-being of its people.

Please note that the views expressed in this article are of the author and do not necessarily reflect the views or policies of any organization.

Sadia Jabeen is an Assistant Professor at Management Sciences Department, Ibadat International University Islamabad

References of the studies can be provided on demand by the author sadia.jabeem@dms.iiui.edu.pk

Related Stories