Importance of Agriculture in Pakistan: Ensuring Food Security and Rural Livelihoods

Agriculture is the cornerstone of Pakistan's economy, employing a significant portion of the population and contributing substantially to the nation's Gross Domestic Product (GDP). According to Pakistan's Economic Survey 2024, 37.4% of the workforce is engaged in agriculture, which contributes approximately 24% of the GDP. The sector is not only vital for ensuring food security but also crucial for sustaining rural livelihoods and supporting related industries such as textiles and food processing. However, challenges such as the misuse of subsidies, inefficient resource allocation, and mismanagement of government aid programs hinder the sector's growth and long-term sustainability. Addressing these issues requires a comprehensive strategy that focuses on improving resource utilization, enhancing transparency, and promoting accountability within the agricultural sector.

Veterinary Assistance Support and Agricultural Subsidies

The Pakistani government and various agricultural institutions have launched numerous programs to assist farmers in boosting productivity and enhancing food security. For instance, the Economic Survey of Pakistan 2024 reveals that PKR 50 billion was allocated for agricultural subsidies, with an additional PKR 20 billion designated for veterinary services during the fiscal year. These initiatives aim to provide farmers with the necessary resources to improve agricultural production, strengthen rural economies, and ensure food security for the growing population.

A key component of these support programs is training sessions organized for farmers in rural areas. During these weeklong workshops, both male and female farmers are provided with training on running small businesses, agricultural best practices, and sustainable farming techniques. Participants receive daily meals and, upon completion, are given veterinary pharmaceuticals worth PKR 50,000 to help them establish and maintain their businesses. These programs are designed to empower farmers with the skills and resources they need to thrive in an increasingly competitive agricultural landscape.

Challenges and Misuse of Resources

Despite the government's well-intentioned efforts, instances of misuse and mismanagement of resources are common, undermining the effectiveness of these support programs. One recurring issue is that some farmers sell the stock they receive—such as veterinary medicines or subsidized fertilizers—rather than using it to improve their farms. This not only diminishes the intended benefits of the programs but also tarnishes the reputation of the service providers involved.

The impact of this misuse is far-reaching. Mismanagement of funds and resources can lead to inefficiencies in agricultural production, resulting in lower crop yields and diminished livestock health. For instance, according to a report by Dawn News, there is a long history of waste and fraud in farm subsidies in Pakistan, with funds being diverted or misused, often leading to inflated prices for basic agricultural inputs. These inefficiencies further exacerbate existing problems within the sector, including low productivity, soil degradation, and poor financial management among farmers.

Real-World Insights: Farmer Behavior and Mismanagement

Conversations with farmers and field observations reveal a pattern of behavior that undermines the long-term objectives of government support programs. In some instances, farmers focus more on the immediate benefits—such as free meals and veterinary medicines—provided during training sessions, rather than the long-term advantages of adopting sustainable farming practices. This shortsighted approach hinders the overall effectiveness of the programs, leading to missed opportunities for improving productivity and rural livelihoods.

The consequences of this behavior are profound. Mismanagement and misuse of resources contribute to a loss of trust between farmers and institutions, making it more difficult for genuine farmers to access necessary assistance. This can lead to tighter regulations and more bureaucratic hurdles, further complicating the process for those who are genuinely in need of support. Moreover, when resources are not properly utilized, agricultural production drops, resulting in missed opportunities for economic growth and improvement in rural communities.

Solutions and Recommendations

To address these challenges, a multifaceted approach is required, focusing on transparency, accountability, and efficient resource use. The following are key strategies that can be implemented to improve the responsible use of agricultural resources in Pakistan:

1. Improved Screening Processes

Institutions must implement stringent screening processes to ensure that assistance reaches those who genuinely need it. Field inspections and audits should be conducted more frequently to monitor the proper allocation and utilization of resources. This would involve employing technology such as GPS tracking and digital record-keeping systems to track the distribution of subsidies and verify their usage. For instance, the government could establish an online portal where farmers can register for assistance and upload proof of their agricultural activities, allowing for better monitoring and accountability.

Independent third-party auditors should also be employed to ensure transparency in the process. Regular audits of government support programs will help identify inefficiencies, reduce instances of fraud, and ensure that resources are being used effectively to improve agricultural production.

2. Community Involvement and Accountability

Local groups and community leaders play a critical role in fostering transparency and accountability among farmers and institutions. By involving local leaders in the distribution of resources and monitoring of farming activities, communities can ensure the fair and effective use of government aid. For example, community-based organizations could be empowered to oversee the allocation of subsidies and training programs, ensuring that resources are distributed equitably and that farmers are adhering to the guidelines set out by the government.

Additionally, community-led monitoring programs can provide valuable feedback on the effectiveness of government initiatives and highlight areas that require further attention. This grassroots approach ensures that farmers have a vested interest in the success of the programs and helps to build trust between farmers and institutions.

3. Follow-Up Programs and Continuous Monitoring

Follow-up programs are essential for ensuring that the resources provided to farmers are being used effectively. Regular follow-up visits by agricultural extension officers can help identify any issues early on and provide the necessary guidance to address them. These follow-up programs should focus on providing ongoing technical support to farmers, ensuring that they continue to adopt sustainable farming practices and make efficient use of the resources available to them.

Furthermore, follow-up programs can help gather valuable data on the long-term impact of agricultural support initiatives. By tracking the progress of farmers over time, the government can make more informed decisions about future policy changes and resource allocation.

4. Incentivizing Efficient Resource Use

Farmers should be incentivized to make the most of the resources they have. This can be achieved by offering financial rewards for increased crop yields, reduced water usage, and improved labor productivity. For instance, the government could introduce a system of agricultural performance-based payments, where farmers receive bonuses for adopting sustainable practices and achieving certain production targets.

Investing in infrastructure, such as irrigation systems and storage facilities, can also help farmers make better use of their resources. By improving water management and reducing post-harvest losses, farmers can increase their productivity and contribute to the overall growth of the agricultural sector.

5. Leveraging Islamic Teachings for Resource Utilization

The principles of resource utilization are deeply rooted in Islamic teachings, which emphasize the responsible and efficient use of resources for the benefit of society. The Holy Quran states: "The example of those who spend their wealth in the cause of Allah is that of a grain that sprouts into seven ears, each bearing one hundred grains. And Allah multiplies the reward even more to whoever He wills. For Allah is All-Bountiful, All-Knowing" (2:261). This verse highlights the concept of investing resources wisely for greater returns, serving as a moral and ethical foundation for promoting efficient resource use among farmers.

By framing agricultural support initiatives within the context of Islamic teachings, policymakers can encourage farmers to act as responsible stewards of the resources entrusted to them. This approach not only aligns with the cultural and religious values of the majority of Pakistani farmers but also promotes a sense of accountability and social responsibility.

Case Studies and Real-World Examples

Several countries have implemented successful agricultural support programs that can serve as models for Pakistan. In India, the Pradhan Mantri Fasal Bima Yojana (PMFBY) program provides crop insurance to farmers, protecting them against crop losses due to natural disasters. By offering financial protection, the program encourages farmers to adopt more sustainable and productive farming practices, ensuring the long-term viability of the agricultural sector.

Similarly, Brazil's "Zero Hunger" initiative, launched in 2003, focuses on reducing poverty and food insecurity through a combination of government support, community involvement, and sustainable agricultural practices. By providing farmers with access to technical training, financial assistance, and market opportunities, the program has helped reduce hunger and improve rural livelihoods.

Pakistan can draw valuable lessons from these programs by focusing on transparency, accountability, and the promotion of sustainable farming practices. By learning from international best practices, the country can strengthen its agricultural sector and ensure long-term food security for its population.

Conclusion

Empowering farmers through responsible use of agricultural resources is crucial for the sustainable growth and development of Pakistan's agricultural sector. By addressing the issues of resource misuse, enhancing transparency, and promoting efficient resource allocation, the government and agricultural institutions can create a more resilient and productive agricultural system. The implementation of improved screening processes, community involvement, continuous monitoring, and incentivizing efficient resource use will help farmers maximize their potential and contribute to the overall prosperity of the nation.

By leveraging Islamic teachings on resource stewardship and drawing lessons from successful international agricultural programs, Pakistan can promote responsible resource use among farmers and ensure the continued growth of its agricultural sector. With a comprehensive and multifaceted approach, the country can strengthen its agricultural foundations, improve food security, and enhance the livelihoods of millions of rural families.

Please note that the views expressed in this article are of the author and do not necessarily reflect the views or policies of any organization.

Wardah Naqvi and Sami Ullah are PhD Scholars and Raza Ullah is an Associate Professor at the Institute of Agricultural and Resource Economics, University of Agriculture, Faisalabad.

Related Stories